paypal vs other gateways on shopify: when to switch?, paypal vs other gateways on shopify

PayPal VS Other Gateways On Shopify: When To Switch?

When should I move away from PayPal to another payment gateway on my Shopify store? I’m tired if paying such high fees to PayPal.

We hear you. I get asked this question a lot, and it can be hard to say exactly when it’s worthwhile to open up other payment gateways for your shopify customers. This post will tell you when and why. I’ll be honest – it can be a complex topic, with some calculations required to figure out whether it’s worth it for you or not. Ready?

Why consider moving away from PayPal?

First up, let’s consider the advantages of PayPal:

  • Relatively easy to set up
  • Free accounts – no monthly fees
  • Very easy to integrate with Shopify
  • Widely accepted – can be used by customers in most countries

Now, the downsides:

  • You pay the same in fees, regardless of how many transactions you do. (In some regions, the fees go down when you do more transactions, see here for an example).
  • This means that, as you grow, PayPal becomes more expensive.

Example: PayPal Versus eWay (interchange with yours as needed)

Example: Typical PayPal rates are 2.4% + 30c per transaction.

If you make a sale of $100, PayPal will keep $2.70 and give you the rest. When you’re first starting out, this is fine.

However, if you do 100 times that amount: you make sales of $10,000, Paypal keeps $270. This can start to add up.

With other gateways like EWay in Australia and others around the world, the more transactions you do, the less you pay per transaction. More transactions, lower percentage.

A Free Tool You Can Use Right Now: Is it worth it for YOU to switch?

Using the spreadsheet below – which is available as a free download at the bottom of this post – is an example comparison. You will need to fill in some numbers of your own, based on your payment gateway, bank, and own setup.

For a store doing $30,000 per month, it no longer makes sense to use PayPal; it’s better to pay an annual fee and pay less per transaction.

Using the assumptions in the example spreadsheet (below): With PayPal, fees would be $810.00. If you applied for the discount and were accepted, it could be less. With eWay based on a 2% bank rate, $757.00. Comparison chart of eWay versus PayPal transaction fees, highlighting total costs for each payment gateway, relevant for Shopify merchants evaluating payment options.

Want to compare your favorite gateway with PayPal?

  1. Check out the available Shopify compatible gateways in your country here.
  2. Go to their pricing page.
  3. Plug their pricing – and your country’s PayPal pricing – into the spreadsheet below. It will tell you whether it’s worthwhile or not.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD the free comparison spreadsheet: PayPal VS Other Gateways On Shopify

Think this sounds convoluted or boring? I wouldn’t blame you – but spending a few minutes could save you thousands of dollars this year. Isn’t it worth it?

***

Thank you for showing interest in our Shopify Insider Blog @ Blackbelt Commerce. Please make sure to check out our products. We also have some top blog recommendations for you to check out; Vendor Page In Shopifyshopify incoming sales, the most exciting e-commerce marketing trends,  and Sell More On Your Shopify Store.  Keep a lookout for new blog posts.

Do you have any questions? We’ll be happy to answer them in the comments. Kizunaquant 評判

Add Comment

Your email address will not be published.Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

;

Add Comment

Your email address will not be published.Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Book a Free Strategy Call

Ready to grow your organic revenue?

BOOK YOUR STRATEGIC CALL
614%avg. organic traffic increase
1,000+Shopify merchants served
5.0 / 5Shopify partner rating
Official Partner:Shopify

Trusted by 1,000+ Shopify Merchants

★★★★★
5.0 / 5.0

Rated by 1,000+ Shopify Merchants

Official Partner

Shopify Plus SEO Expert Agency

614%+

Avg. Organic Traffic Increase

Elite Brands

LA Lakers, Judith Leiber & More

Certified Shopify Plus SEO Expert & Premier Shopify SEO Agency — Serving Stores Since 2015
Verified Client Results

Real Shopify Stores. Real Results.

These aren’t projections — these are verified revenue and traffic results achieved for real Shopify merchants.

ECOMMERCE SEO STRATEGY
Erica Wilson
Shopify 2.0 + AI SEO
+614%Organic Traffic
Organic Traffic
3K → 27.7K
Revenue
$19K → $153K
Timeframe
3 months
LOCAL SEO + SHOPIFY
Biltmore Avenue Family Dentistry
Local Business + Shopify Store
+340%Revenue Growth
Page 1 Rankings
2 → 15+ keywords
Organic Revenue
3x in 6 months
Timeframe
6 months

What Our Clients Say

★★★★★

“I’ve been working with Cesar for several years. Blackbelt has been instrumental in growing our online business through their program that actually works.”

JG
Jeremy Granger
Biltmore Avenue Family Dentistry
★★★★★

“Blackbelt Commerce is a great team to work with. They are extremely knowledgeable in terms of site design, functionality, and SEO.”

JM
Jana Matheson
Judith Leiber NY
★★★★★

“Starting this project I had a vision and Blackbelt Commerce delivered beyond what I expected. I highly recommend them for any ecommerce SEO strategy.”

FH
Falon Henley
Ultimate Weapons
$3M+
Top Client Revenue
614%
Max Traffic Growth
7.5x
Revenue Multiplier
5★
Client Reviews

Ready to start? Call us directly:

+1 (516) 494-7679

Or book a free strategy call online

Frequently Asked Questions

Get answers to the most common questions about our AI SEO services.

What is AI SEO and how is it different from traditional SEO?

AI SEO optimizes your Shopify store to be discovered and recommended by AI platforms like ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, and Claude — not just traditional search engines. While traditional SEO focuses on keyword rankings and backlinks, AI SEO focuses on structured data, semantic authority, entity optimization, and content that AI systems can parse and cite directly.

How do AI search engines find and recommend Shopify stores?

AI search engines crawl your site’s structured data (Product schema, FAQ schema, reviews), analyze your content’s topical authority, evaluate your brand’s entity presence across the web, and assess technical signals like page speed and mobile experience.

Will AI SEO replace traditional SEO for my Shopify store?

No — AI SEO complements traditional SEO. You still need strong Google rankings, but AI search is growing rapidly. Our approach ensures your store is optimized for both: traditional search engines for direct traffic, and AI platforms for recommendation-based discovery.

How long does it take to see results from AI SEO?

Most clients see measurable improvements within 60-90 days. AI search platforms update their indexes frequently, so optimizations like structured data, entity markup, and content restructuring can show impact relatively quickly compared to traditional SEO.

What Shopify stores benefit most from AI SEO?

Any Shopify store selling products that people research before buying benefits from AI SEO. This includes health and wellness, fashion, electronics, home goods, specialty foods, and B2B products. If customers ask questions before purchasing, AI SEO helps your store appear in those answers.

Do you optimize for ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, and Perplexity?

Yes. Our AI SEO program covers all major AI search platforms including ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews (SGE), Perplexity, Claude, and Bing Copilot. Each platform has different ranking signals, and our framework addresses all of them.

What is included in your AI SEO audit?

Our AI SEO audit analyzes your current AI search visibility, structured data implementation, content semantic structure, entity presence across the web, technical SEO health, and competitor AI visibility. You receive a detailed report with prioritized recommendations.

How much does AI SEO cost?

AI SEO programs start at $2,500/month for ongoing optimization or $5,000-$15,000 for one-time optimization projects. The investment depends on your store’s size, current SEO foundation, and growth goals. Contact us for a custom quote.

Can you show examples of AI SEO results?

Yes. Our clients have seen 614% organic traffic increases, 340% revenue growth, and consistent appearances in AI-generated product recommendations. We share detailed case studies during our strategy calls.

Do I need traditional SEO before starting AI SEO?

Not necessarily. While a solid traditional SEO foundation helps, we can implement AI SEO alongside traditional optimizations. Many of the technical improvements — structured data, site architecture, content optimization — benefit both traditional and AI search simultaneously.

Ready to Grow Your AI Search Visibility?

Book a free 30-minute strategy call. We’ll analyze your store’s AI search presence and outline a custom growth plan.

GET YOUR FREE AI SEO AUDIT

Or call us directly: +1 (516) 494-7679